Oh, the humble corn cob pipe! They seem to be one of those "love them or hate them" things in "Smokedom". Personally I dig them. I've got 20-30 really nice briar pipes, and probably 50 cobs. I'm afraid to lay them all out and take inventory for fear the wife would catch me and have a real conniption fit. For those unfamiliar with that Southern term, suffice it to say it wouldn't be pretty.
But I digress. I find myself grabbing a cob over a briar more often than not when I want to smoke a pipe
Mistakes are made in pipe-making, just like in anything else. Or sometimes, the finished product just doesn't turn out "just right". Most briar pipe makers either toss those, or sell them as seconds or "basket pipes". Missouri Meerschaum, the undisputed king of cob manufacturers, does the same thing but different. They offer a "10 Pipe Grab Bag of Smokable Seconds" for around $40/shipped. I've picked up a couple over the last few years. Some are downright ugly, with chips on the rim, too much lacquer and/or plaster, but as advertised, they have all been smokable and worth the money. I've picked up some real gems, though, including a Cobbit, a General, and a couple of acorn Diplomats (no longer made) in the first grab-bag I ordered.
The less-attractive ones get relegated to smoking while grilling, mowing the grass, and general "yard-gar" duties. The better looking pipes I play around with. One of the biggest complaints about cobs from "briar purists" are that cobs are just too rustic and simple looking. I beg to differ. This is a "Country Gentleman" out of the last grab bag I ordered. A little Fiebing's burgundy leather dye, a 50 cent amber stem...