I think two things hurt this cigar and it's sales and really neither has to do with the quality or pure enjoyment of the smoke. First this was over hyped, coming out of the 2016 ICPCR it was heralded as the collaboration of two titans, cant miss blend. The second strike against it is the price, i feel the MSRP was bumped above keystone pricing because the blenders and everyone expected to run to it, just because how could a cigar by Drew and Caldwell not be good. Yes good reviews and bad reviews, but if you read some of the good reviews like Halfwheel, who gave it a 90, even they say to pricey.
I am not telling anyone what to smoke, just putting out my opinion. But at 40% off it brings it more in line